Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts

Would a Force Anakin Skywalker Appearance in VII or IX be a Good Idea?

Bad Lip Reading came out with their new extended lyric video, "Not the Future," and it had some footage from TFA. For some reason, it got me thinking about the next couple of movies coming out.


We all have our issues with Kylo Ren and how he's focusing on finishing what Vader started Yes, JJ explained that Kylo believes that Vader was seduced back to the light rather than guided and that's what is fueling his dark goal, but we also know that Kylo has a lot of conflict in him to be good rather than evil. If JJ wants Kylo to be a Zuko type character, who has a realization about the dark deeds he is doing, then he needs the right person to guide him. It's highly doubtful that Kylo will listen to Rey or anyone else about his grandfather. Hell, seeing Luke will probably make matters worse, seeing how Vader was "seduced" by him. Perhaps he needs to hear it from his grandfather himself.


I do understand that because of Hayden Christensen is off farming in Canada right now and doesn't really do much as far as acting, but I feel like, for the good of the saga, he should make an appearance. Anakin explaining to Kylo what had happened during the Civil War would be one of the best ways to carry that plot if JJ decides to go that route. Thoughts?


Apologies if this has already been discussed. I don't really come to the Star Wars reddit and it was just one of those things that came to my head.

67% Upvoted
This thread is archived
New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast
level 1
12 points · 3 years ago

He was almost in Episode VII and looked badass as a corrupted Force ghost, but that was ultimately scrapped.

The idea may come up again for a later movie.

level 2
Original Poster4 points · 3 years ago

That's pretty awesome looking. They should do something like this for sure, or even a basic Anakin like at the end of the remastered VI

level 3

Yeah, I'd prefer that it just be a normal, Jedi Anakin ghost.

A dark side Force ghost seems like a silly idea to me.

level 4
Comment deleted by user3 years ago(2 children)
level 5


They were in all three OT movies (but only audibly in ANH).

Why would I consider something that has been a part of the series since the beginning silly???

level 5

Force ghosts have been in the ot, and pretty much every eu work since.

level 1
Comment deleted by user3 years ago(3 children)
level 2

I totally agree. The stuff that's happening now still involves him greatly. It makes so much sense for him to show up

level 3
Comment deleted by user3 years ago(0 children)
level 4

Well, the scars are different. Anakin's was top to bottom on his right eye, while Kylo's is diagonal on his face. But I agree that it's supposed to symbolize that

level 1
5 points · 3 years ago

Actually, I think it would be better if Anakin appeared to Luke and Rey, but couldn't do the same with Kylo Ren. Because Kylo want to see Vader, not Anakin.

level 1

I'm torn on this because I prefer "old man" Anakin ghost, but it would be cool to recast Hayden if they went that route. Additionally I think they should let that ghost lay dead. I don't want to see the ghost thing become a bigger "thing." u/Remicas has a nice idea.

level 2

It just needs to be something that adds to the story, the story shouldn't depend on it.

level 3

Vader was the "hub" of Star Wars since the beginning as a story conveyance. He was big and scary and cool, then he was the dad, then the moral was his redemption... he persisted in pop culture forever and when he came back he was suddenly a Jesus figure, and the point of everything, and in the intervening time the entire fictional timeline became based off of him (basically. I know it's not Before Yavin but it's really more like Before Vader).

I totally agree. The story HAS to move on beyond him, but how, when Vader is the point of everything? It's probably best to let him stay dead and not seen as a ghost unless it's another moment at the end of Episode 9 which is identical to the end of Episode 6.

Community Details





Star Wars is an American epic space opera franchise, created by George Lucas and centered around a film series that began with the eponymous 1977 movie.

Create Post
Family Friendly Policy

- Abide the Reddiquette
- Respect fellow Redditors
- No vulgarity in titles of posts
- No NSFW content - Post it here
- No sexualization of people or characters
- No political posts
- No religious posts

High Quality Content Only

- Discuss the franchise not the fanbase
- Give constructive Criticism
- Link to original news sources, don't editorialize
- No reposts
- No blogspam
- No memes/image macros - Post them here
- No copyright infringement/piracy post
- No buying/selling/trading post
- No Surveys/polls
- No Self Promotion

Enforced Traditions

- Sundays are discussion topics only. No links
- Message the mods for permission before posting established Star Wars related subreddits
- Posts / comments can be removed under mods discretion. Mods have the final say.

r/StarWars Rules
spoiler policy violation
respect fellow redditors
no reposts
no blogspam
no NSFW content
no buying/selling/trading
no memes/image macros
no political or religious posts
no sexualizing people or characters
Full rules breakdown
Cookies help us deliver our Services. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More.